In Paris, I was part of Bresson’s world. Only here, I was the one behind the camera, a silent witness to the flow of people on the streets, making way for the natural synthesis of scenes to happen to the camera. Each corner I turned around, there was a frame lying in wait. On the streets of Paris, as you know, the frames are numerous. You are hard-pressed to let go of any. Such as on the noon before we walked to Montmartre – when we sat in a tiny, packed café to a meal of succulent roast chicken, fries and red wine.
At the café’s counter, a man sat perched upon a barstool, a French Bulldog in attendance. Now, as all examples of his species go, this bulldog was undeniably ugly. Clownish bat ears, bow legs, flat face, bulging eyes. But what he had in spades was determination. He must have a bite off the table behind him, just laid with food. Naturally, he went and stood, a pugnacious little fellow, at the foot of the table. The man eating at that table turned around to let his displeasure be obvious to the bulldog’s human who cast a sheepish smile and muttered, ‘Jack non, non’ in reproval. He tightened Jack’s leash around the leg of his barstool. But this Jack, he was a trooper. He wormed his way back to the table a few times, till his man friend used his foot to wedge Jack’s face against the counter. Picture Jack then. A sorrowful expression on his face, the least he could demand was discretion.
I clicked a photo of him accordingly, discreetly, while imparting sagacious words to this oddball, ‘Life never came with a promise to be fair, Jack’.
In the lengthening shadows of that cold and blustery noon, we carried on to Montmartre, making pit stops at small boutiques along cobbled streets. The rigours of daily life in the metro unfolded along us. Men loaded and unloaded vans.
Montmartre turned out to be divested of the summer crowds. It was easier to lend your mind to the reason it is called ‘the Mount of the Martyr’. The martyr in question is Saint Denis, the first bishop of Paris. This patron saint was decapitated by the Romans because, much to the alarm of the Roman priests, he was gaining followers rapidly. When I saw his statue, it seemed like he had his hands over his ears, but actually the man was holding his own head. The legend is that he was beheaded by a bored Roman soldier. But the saint did not give up. He picked up his head and continued walking to the top of the hill. Eventually, he dropped dead and his head rolled till it reached a spot where the Basilica of Saint Denis was built.
The neighbourhood of Montmartre looks decidedly posh with its old churches and chapels, a line-up of chic bistros and pavement drinkers, boulangeries like Alexine where the cheese & nut breads, not to forget the tarts, are guaranteed to drive you into a frenzy.
You would almost forget that this was the Paris of broke artists; of walled gardens; of poorly-lit garretts cluttered with easels, redolent of turpentine and paint; of artists’ communes frequented Picasso, Matisse, Modigliani; of drunken brawls, idealistic talk and angst-ridden thoughts spewed at guinguettes (outdoor taverns-cum–dance halls); slow waltzes to the tune of the accordion. And gradually the paths drifting down to the louche neighbourhood of Pigalle which the surrealist André Breton described as “diamantiferous mud”. A notorious collection of seedy nightclubs, erotic museum, porn theatres offering peep shows and what not, to the iconic cabaret of the Moulin Rouge.
If you would come with me, we could walk the leafy, loopy alleys of the 18th arrondissement together, skim through street art, take breaks at intimate little cafés, and break the silence once in a while to wonder about the Montmartre that has been left behind.
ARUNDHATI BASU 
Dotty,
Your photos and commentary are sheer joy to behold. The comments re: Hitler and Speer. It’s interesting that once the war had turned against Germany that Hitler had ordered the complete destruction of Paris. Fortunately, the general receiving the orders was a soldier and not a barbarian. Hitler would rather destroy everything he could not have. Such a little man in so many ways.
On another note, your choosing to use B&W was so appropriate to convey the spirit of the city. Excellent! may I ask what camera you used?
LikeLike
Samsung Galaxy S8 Plus (Bresson would have fainted).
Thank you for the kind words! 🙂
A little man — that possibly captures his personality best. Actually we might run out of adjectives here. Isn’t there such irony in his appreciation of a city that he aimed to destroy? The stories from WWII are fascinating. I cannot get enough of them.
LikeLike
Great captures Dippy, Paris c’est tres jolie!!!
LikeLike
Thank you Paulo! Paris is truly wonderful.
LikeLike
Great black and white photos. You even got a good shot of the details of a Wallace Fountain, which are really hard to capture in a photo.
LikeLike
Thank you so. Wallace Fountains…there you go. I just could not remember for the life of me!
LikeLike
I was a bit taken aback by the statue of St. Denis but then I thought this would be a perfect way to alleviate one of my migraine headaches 😉 Wonderful blogpost and photos! – Neek
LikeLike
Take off your head?! 😀 Thanks Neek! Much appreciated. xx
LikeLike
Well, it sounded good at the time…. Hee Hee!
LikeLike
😀 😀
LikeLike
Dippy, I’m loving your black and white atmospheric photos of Paris! It’s been ages since I walked around 18th but felt as if I was there with you.
LikeLike
Sheree, thank you. 🙂 I bet there are stories you have to tell about your ambles through Montmartre. Winter added to its charm. xx
LikeLike
I’ve been to Montmartre every time I’ve been to Paris, yet there are places in these photos I still haven’t been! What a magical little place.
LikeLike
Thank you, Arielle. It is possible to miss things in every place we travel to, is it not? But that is the charm of repeat travel, to see a place more thoroughly. I enjoy the process of seeing places time and again. As for Montmartre, I loved the quiet winter vibes of it. Cheers! xx
LikeLike
Oh I do adore this district of Paris. Montmartre has such a unique charm about it doesn’t it?
Your photos are just magnificent.
Have a great weekend lovely. X
LikeLike
Thank you, Lorelle. I had to force myself from not putting up more because my fingers were quite busy. Those alleys of Montmartre were entrancing. More so, because there were no crowds. 🙂
You have a fun weekend too. xx
LikeLike
Oh I have to agree with you there about the crowds! You were there in December right?
Though the last time we went in September, crowds weren’t too bad. Not as bad as July/ August 🤦♀️
LikeLike
Yes. That said, the last time I visited it was in autumn which I adored. The crowds were manageable then – you are right.
LikeLike
I felt like I was in Montmartre reading this post. Wonderful. Poor Jack. And I love the ‘diamantiferous mud’ description of Pigalle. That could still apply. Montmartre might have changed beyond recognition, but Pigalle is still sleazy.
LikeLike
Thank you Tracey. 🙂 Poor Jack indeed. Once in a wee while, it is not a dog’s life!
LikeLike
I’m loving your B&W tour of Paris. What a great idea to showcase Paris. I’m also loving all the bistros and boulangeries and biscuiteries, and the fact that some stoic Parisians are sitting outside. Poor St. Denis!
LikeLike
Thank you, Caroline! I quite liked the idea of Determined Denis.
The best part about sitting outside is the hint of chill along with the wonderful warmth radiated by the patio heaters … and a glass of red wine to go with it. 🙂
LikeLike
I have just revisited your beautiful post. We are heading to Paris in a few days and I can’t wait to explore this part of the city. Hope all is well with you guys!
LikeLike
Hey Caroline, good to hear from you. Are you in Paris still? We have been traipsing all around Tuscany and then some of the Balkans. So been quite off the blogging circuit but hope to get back to it soon. Safe travels! xx
LikeLike
A superb Paris stroll ma’amji. Your B&W focus does bring out the winter grey. Really fab.
(I could almost feel the cold…)
I love the Passe-Muraille. My sister used to live nearby and it was our usual route up.
Much easier that taking the stairs which are bloody murder.
Now the “magasin d’habits”? I’m almost positive i’ve passed by last year.
Need to check my files.
Be good.
LikeLike
Merci beaucoup! The Passe Muraille is unique. I have not seen the likes of it anywhere else and it quite stuck in my mind. That lane up was lovely. Your sister lived in a lovely spot.
Did you mean the Rue Houdon boutique?
LikeLike
That statue was made to honour Marcel Aymé, a French writer who lived nearby. My father had a lot of his books. I might even have “le passe-muraille” still. Oh, oh! I don’t. Where can it be?
Yes that boutique. Though I’m not sure about the street. That one is coming down from Montmartre to Pigalle and I seem to recall seeing it somewhere else. Maybe a branch. 🙂
LikeLike
Rue Houdon did lead up from the Pigalle.
Hope you found the book!
LikeLike
Nooooo. Flabbergasted! I can see the book. It must be in a box in Paris in my brother’s den. Tsss.
LikeLike
Amen. To finding lost treasures.
LikeLike
I’ve had in mind of getting that stuff back and store it properly. I mean my brother’s been great at storing it for… nearly ten years now, but I need to have another look at what’s in there and probably get a storage room. 🙂 (Don’t we all love treasure hunts?)
LikeLike
Oh yes, and a roomful of books.
LikeLike
As you know I have finally managed to get all my books in a “Library”. (Colonel Mustard and all that). I call the library The India room. 😉 I’ll post why someday.
LikeLike
For the record, I suck at Cluedo. I remember The India Room and it would be an interesting read, this future post.
LikeLike
Never tell a story in advance, spoils the fun. But what I have in mind is a series of photographs of the room, the art, and the books. I could do it tomorrow, my desk is in there! But I always forget.
Cluedo? I think we mentioned it before. 🙂 Winning is not the important thing it’s the atmosphere. I loved that game as a child then played it with our daughters.
Cheers ma’amji.
LikeLike
I have faint stirrings of a Cluedo conversation, now that you mention it. Since I have never won at it, you can imagine it rankles!
As for the post, let the story unfold at your own pace. Cheers.
LikeLike
I think your brother may have cheated. Wouldn’t put it past him. 😉
LikeLike
Heh actually I played it more with Adi and our friends. Adi almost always won.
LikeLike
He’s a system’s engineer, right? Calculating all the odds? (Wrote an application on his phone?)
LikeLike
Non. He is a consultant, into automation (AI). 🙂 But he is darned good at calculating the odds.
LikeLike
Artificial Intelligence. Quite sharp. 🙂
I might not dare play chess with him. 😉
Have a great week.
LikeLike
You too! And yeah, he’s not as daft as me.
LikeLike
Daft you? (How utterly British a word). I don’t believe you for a second.
LikeLike
Oh but what do I say… I am gifted.
LikeLike
No question there. 🙂
LikeLike
PS. You didn’t stay that long in Paris did you? But you seem to have done a good mileage. 🙂
LikeLike
Well 6 days was as good as it got. As for mileage, it was not too bad. Our best was 10 miles on the last night — legs like loose pegs.
LikeLike
That’s not bad. Paris, like New York, or London is a city to walk, and walk, and walk.
Bon week-end, ma’amji.
LikeLike
Have a lovely weekend yourself. 🙂
LikeLike
🙂
LikeLike
Hello beautiful, I am starting to catch up with your blog and what best than your Paris series. How long did you stay in the capital?
I am familiar with some of these gems shown in your pictures but I don’t know the vast majority. Which was your favourite part of the 18th arrondisement? Also, Jack 😍
LikeLike
Six days to be precise, V. One day was reserved for a day trip to the Alsace region.
Thank you, lovely! It is difficult, almost impossible to see everything, isn’t it? Even a local, I bet, does not know and see everything that is around him. The quiet, cobblestoned alleys were my pick there, V, along with the Passe Muraille.
Jack was one of my highlights too, though he was outside of the 18th arrondissement. xxx
LikeLike
I had to look at your post again ma’amji. Bresson indeed. Just fab quality photographs. I don’t think Bresson would have fainted. He would have been very interested. My brother saw him once. In May 68 on the barricades. My brother. Bresson was taking pictures. With a small Leica if I recall.
LikeLike
Why that is mighty rich, Brianji! I am so ill equipped to handle compliments that I end up hemming and hawing at them. Thank you.
The picture you created with the date and the image of barricades, your brother as an onlooker, and Bresson with his Leica…marvellous.
LikeLike
keep hemming and hawing. Well deserved.
And as for my brother he was actually ON the barricade, all for the eyes of a pretty philosophy Maoist student. Both eventually were arrested and tried. Much to the dismay of my parents. Not convicted. I still have the court’s documents! 😉
LikeLike
What an eventful life! Your parents must have been kept on their toes.
LikeLike
They were extremely p.o’d at my brother. Didn’t speak to him for 4 years! 😉
LikeLike
I would say! What children put their parents through is remarkable. But high adventure for your brother.
LikeLike
Indeed. On both counts. 🙂
LikeLike
Beautiful B&W photos! This post reminds me the quote by Thomas Jefferson: “A walk about Paris will provide lessons in history, beauty, and in the point of Life.”
LikeLike
Cheers Megala! Thanks for sharing the quote too. Jefferson clearly found his inspiration in the right place.
LikeLike
What a perfect way to spend a quiet evening… your posts are always a joy to read and the photos are incredible!
LikeLike
You are so kind! Thank you for giving the time of day to my rambles. xx
LikeLike
You weave a magical tale of Paris through your atmospheric BandW pics and descriptive words. It’s been years since I was there but your posts have transported me. Wonderful! 🙂💕
LikeLike
Thank you, Miriam. Memories must have come flooding back.
LikeLike
Love this post. Beautifully written.
LikeLike
Thank you. 🙂
LikeLike
Beautiful pictures! Wait, did you really say ‘Samsung 8 Plus’? Wow!!! Brilliant! And when you mentioned about roast chicken I was quickly reminded about La Fontain de Mars. We had roast chicken there and half the time I was thinking about Mr Obama and Michelle dining there. 🙂
LikeLike
Thank you Amor. Yes, I am a fan of phone cameras. 🙂 There are times though when I feel the absence of an SLR.
Now I have not been to La Fontain de Mars, but sounds like you were in illustrious company. Any time I hear roast chicken, my mouth waters alarmingly. Maybe tonight I shall make it a roast chicken night just to satisfy this sudden craving. 😉 xx
LikeLike
La Fontaine is really just a bistro but yeah I suppose it became famous because of the Obamas. It must be liberating to just bring the phone to take pictures. I still bring along my DSLR you know hahah old school. I plan to buy a mirrorless next time hoping it’d be slimmer.
LikeLike
You know, I wholeheartedly nod in favour of old-school everything. Naturally the DSLR wins the debate effortlessly. xx
LikeLike